Topic, justification & review citation
The first challenge is choosing a topic that you will work with for the remainder of the semester (no pressure). In order to make sure that you will have enough support (orginal research reports) for your topic, you will need to draw that topic from a review article published on or after January 1, 2019.
1.
Choosing a Topic and Finding a Review
In choosing a topic and finding a supporting review, there are two paths you can go down. The divergence of those paths centers around how well formed your idea of a topic is. The two options are:
- No Idea At All
Without a firm idea of a topic, what you will need to do is survey the literature to find a topic. This is a rather daunting undertaking, unless you know where to look for a novel and exciting review article. The first place I would recommend looking is the journal Trends in Biochemical Sciences, also known as TIBS. This journal publishes short reviews (usually under ten pages) on very current topics (both biological systems as well as methods). You can be sure that a recent TIBS review will open to a wealth of active primary literature.
There are some other places to search for a topic and matching review. Many journals publish only reviews, or a reasonable number of reviews in addition to primary research reports. Below is a non-exhaustive list in alphabetical order.
- I Know Exactly What I Would Like To Study
With a firm idea of what you would like to write on, the only challenge is finding a review
paper which matches your topic. To find a review paper on a particular topic, you'll need to
go to an indexing service and search for a matching paper.
PubMed is the largest and most easily accessed index of the biochemical literature (along with medical literature). To find recent review articles at PubMed, limit your search in the following ways:
- Type of Article = Review
- Dates => "Specify date range" => Date Published 2019/01/01 to today
- And any other particulars that might help narrow your search (such as limiting the search to English language journals)
The SciFinder application integrates literature citations with molecular and reaction data. SciFinder will have information about topics of both biochemistry and chemistry, along with chemical engineering and biomedical engineering content. To find a recent review in SciFinder, login, enter your topic/keyword, click "Advanced Search" and limit your search in the following ways:
- Publication Years = 2019-
- Document Types = Review
The Web of Knowledge is a commercial product of Thomson Reuters (formerly Thomson ISI, calculators of the Impact Factor). The web of science catalogs similar content to PubMed and provides links to all citations in a paper as well as links to papers citing that paper (what you need to calculate an impact factor). To find recent review articles in the Web of Knowledge, limit your search in the following ways:
- Uncheck the "Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI)"
- Click the "From" radio button and change the lower end of the range to 2019.
- Restrict the language to English.
- Restrict the document type to "Review."
2.
The Justification
Since you will be committing a grand amount of time toward the study of this topic, now is the time to justify that topic. Why is it valuable for you to research and write on your topic of interest? Now, this isn't just an exercise, scientists (both in academics as well as those in industry, and most everyone else working in research and development) are often ask to justify their work on a particular topic for money, time or both. It is good to be in the habit of knowing the reasons why you work on something and being able to describe those reasons to someone in a short conversation.
Your justification is limited to one paragraph. In that paragraph you should establish the large, over-arching question, your topic in particular as well as argue for the significance or importance of this topic. Another
way to think of these requirements is to picture an hour glass. You would like to bring the reader from all the ideas of the world to your topic and from your narrow topic out to all the ramifications. Now, in one paragraph, you'll need to choose carefully what to include and what to exclude (but don't abandon what you don't use here, it can make its way into your paper).
3.
The Citation
A citation for your review article is the final element you need. All citations in this course will use the style of the journal
Biochemistry, an
American Chemical Society Publication. The format for a citation is given in the
Reference Guidelines. All journals provide a similar document to authors which describes the style guidelines for publication in that journal. While the journal will ulimately be responsible for typesetting the article, the author must prepare their manuscript in the style required by the journal.
At this point, your topic is definitely tentative. As you read more your topic will be refined to better match what you've learned. If you learn that this topic isn't what you'd hoped for, you are free to change topics (you may only wish to exercise this option during the first couple of assignments). If you change topics, it is not necessary to go back and repeat anything, just continue on with your new topic. I will use your topic at each assignment as your current seminar topic.
Your assignment is due on 28 or 30 January, 2026.
Last updated at 15:55:21 on 2026-02-21.
76 page views since 18 December, 2025.
Page generated in 0.004 seconds.